Recommended List: U$ u9 R( n) }0 v# F3 g, T/ G
Compact SUVs
. g* D; ]- {1 g9 N. x" V |
Honda CR-V
+ f' l2 I3 s! K! m' B/ v6 j$ q' b& y2 r( ?
% }% D3 H- H i

2 O) O M2 ~. M6 z; x, f# K | 4 d. O8 r' W! H q% a$ m, W
#1 Editor's PickReasons to buy the Honda CR-V:
! s8 y) M9 w) Z4 E8 e& m8 I- #1 Ranked for safety on the list
- #1 Ranked for quality on the list
- #1 Ranked for Expert Review on the list
- One of the top 3 ranked for gas milage
Reasons not to buy the Honda CR-V:) g3 y3 ^+ B. U! R3 v( Q
- 10th ranked on the list for cost
- Can get the Hyundai Tucson for around $4,000 less
See reviews for this model
+ y1 Y8 b! G; l; G |
Hyundai Tucson
0 v" D8 L: {% H% B6 n1 m2 }& R3 J# _

5 l; z4 y, `$ k7 S% S4 t) {4 ?7 P$ G/ `/ ~: O3 v, D# T* p
| #2 Editor's PickReasons to buy the Hyundai Tucson:$ U2 L, r/ ~! }6 ?; h. q" P
; H; S- C9 Z: W) j! n
- #1 ranked for safety on the list
- One of top 3 ranked for price on the list
Reasons not to buy the Hyundai Tucson:$ Y" m. p0 v7 d& {
- has lower horsepower compared to rest
- want the #1 rated Honda CR-v
See reviews for this model
) H8 G; {$ _" Q: P, m0 p2 s1 Z |
Toyota RAV4
% O6 N& P. V. `2 B* M& X5 H) P+ k8 A/ c E9 V# ?3 A# o
" _* ?; ^' `' F3 C+ x
| #3 Editor's PickReasons to buy the Toyota RAV4:
3 e- P. O6 w. b6 e, j
/ P- U/ X8 _$ S9 @+ P1 o8 E2 E- #1 ranked fuel economy on the list
- runner up next to Honda CR-V for quality
- runner up for expert review
- #1 ranked for value on the list
- Agile and economical
Reasons not to buy the Toyota RAV4:
2 N4 M7 J) L- }: ^* h* C/ I3 o: q- want the Honda CR-V
- low horsepower rating
See reviews for this model
2 V8 @+ P3 k3 k5 X |
Jeep Patriot : [4 N7 m# o" W# U; N* A
8 m7 q' c* p5 Z: G$ \4 s$ g% b9 j
2 Q) K0 Y) ^8 u/ e, J/ C$ G) G# n& `/ a
| #4 Editor's PickReasons to buy the Jeep Patriot:
0 g5 Y- _1 ?7 ^/ V
8 Q) m( J' B& A8 g+ ]% P- #1 ranked for gas mileage
- #1 ranked for price
- One of the top ten for safety
- good off road capability
Reasons not to buy the Jeep Patriot:
$ K' s; [! l' N1 `, p- Cab is pretty noisy
- comes standard with just a one cd system
- small fuel tank
- not a great deal of cargo space in rear
See reviews for this model
: O4 B1 N" o6 G |
Saturn Vue7 B6 {9 l7 I) X0 a
8 |' h e5 w. r2 W5 J3 L6 q8 m7 m# @' { 1 d+ _& c5 p0 B, a( R8 @; E% `* J
9 T* Z- r8 K1 g( w0 x9 j8 b! d$ z | #5 Editor's PickReasons to buy the Saturn Vue:$ n6 K5 r. ]0 _" ^, M
: g: k. @2 h+ Y$ N' r; Q8 X- Great Gas Mileage
- Onstar feature
- quiet engine
- Ranked #4 on the list for price
- Good horsepower
Reasons not to buy the Saturn Vue:
2 z: f7 x {5 d0 C- low rank under total value
- could get the Hyundai Tucson cheaper
See reviews for this model ?% n0 I5 c; f" ~; K
|
Kia Sportage
3 N4 j8 \2 W0 _# l6 `! w' B3 b9 |6 v' ]8 Y3 q( Q+ N- @! A
8 n/ |5 Z0 x/ r# w; m4 F5 n; q
5 H Q) [7 w) D4 T | #6 Editor's PickReasons to buy the Kia Sportage:
# w9 `2 y7 F z; e' V8 c, S! ]% O5 _' X. P* k6 |
- runner up for best price behind the Jeep Patriot
- decent gas mileage
- #3 ranked in value
Reasons not to buy the Kia Sportage:
, E9 ` v7 Y: B- low ranking horsepower
- want the Jeep Patriot
See reviews for this model) Y4 G& R' G- K) E; ?
|
Subaru Forester7 P+ t0 q7 b, t1 Y d9 u
6 W# p# u. `$ S4 z

# K3 O! P4 h0 `5 m2 K | #7 Editor's PickReasons to buy the Subaru Forester:3 X4 U [3 G H$ B$ z+ F7 Q
( v& H8 \! N( f- U& x! _* ?
- #1 ranked for safety on the list
- #3 ranked for value on list
- decent gas mileage
Reasons not to buy the Subaru Forester:6 ]: M* X( L8 D1 X& Y$ }: ?9 g
- No Acceleration
- road noise
- lack of leg room in rear
See reviews for this model
% z" L9 c0 K0 l4 P3 _ |
Kia Sorento9 w% r$ n. F1 ~! w/ R+ J
; X) ]6 r# D4 v) y; q- H
4 S* m1 v7 r* }
: d5 E2 j& k8 v" C5 ~
s. U- h$ \" S( c- T0 J& G | #8 Editor's PickReasons to buy the Kia Sorento:+ g! O7 u0 Z* r2 n4 D* `
$ q" V/ u A0 V9 Z, Z" O, T6 O
- #1 ranked horsepower on list
- Value
- exterior and interior styling
Reasons not to buy the Kia Sorento:
5 d) \3 W. i0 a1 Y- low rank for gas mileage
- low towing ability
See reviews for this model
6 ], f! m7 {/ ~, c4 l |
Honda Element9 k+ D9 b& g$ R& a n
8 I) X5 P3 {5 u+ U9 b0 }

; j! N) e5 a7 ]0 L" B& V$ I* |: O1 S) V/ P3 C
| #9 Editor's PickReasons to buy the Honda Element:1 Z0 t. R# c1 r$ ~
1 x# `) N/ D, f ~- q5 G
- good gas mileage
- interior space
- Lots of leg room for front and back passengers
Reasons not to buy the Honda Element:
& C8 l- ?$ Z l& u# W5 r- some road noise
- low horsepower
See reviews for this model( H! C @' i( Q# T! f/ ]
|
Suzuki Grand Vitara 6 h5 i* v9 b) c2 G4 l0 p
; j( x6 n2 |; o. Q" f
| #10 Editor's PickReasons to buy the Suzuki Grand Vitara:) e- C: y9 j9 F
0 d0 |8 E. q# F- e
- smooth ride
- decent pricing
- average rank in safety
Reasons not to buy the Suzuki Grand Vitara:
! P( U! g& \9 e: {' n+ h7 p% y- ranked low on gas mileage
- sluggish acceleration
See reviews for this model
( [- N6 }, X9 r |
Ford Freestyle
/ G5 H5 I9 H1 t& ?# F, H0 W- s, o1 S) }: ]6 W& n
| #11 Editor's PickReasons to buy the Ford Freestyle:
+ }6 g+ |" ?+ d# Z1 x/ `+ L
# ?" i* A3 @" g% o) j- #1 ranked in safety on the list
- decent power balance
- car-like ride
Reasons not to buy the Ford Freestyle:
3 K+ f+ D6 ]" y) h- high priced
- low ranked in value
- could improve in gas mileage
See reviews for this model$ T. X) a+ i0 J6 s5 j; e9 ?8 U, Y
|
Pontiac Torrent 3 h: [& y( ]" c1 U3 H/ u/ Y) p3 D/ Q
/ t0 u" o5 r: ?! ?
| #12 Editor's PickReasons to buy the Pontiac Torrent:* C4 j( h# Z, @! l( { q
% W# ^: J$ A8 A p9 H( I7 n4 U6 `- #1 ranked for safety on the list
- Good overall value for the price
- Nice interior
Reasons not to buy the Pontiac Torrent:
8 S& L5 ^0 U' d3 q. L- ranked low for price
- can do better for fuel economy
|
Jeep Wrangler $ J, v8 l. d O [$ \! @
# U) \# z+ m+ X3 j
| #13 Editor's PickReasons to buy the Jeep Wrangler:7 |; ^- B' @4 `: A2 ?, _
F) R, S3 y) F0 I$ u$ W) l
- #1 ranked in value on the list
- high ranked in quality on the list
- good priced
Reasons not to buy the Jeep Wrangler:% |" O h8 x L- [% P. \
- gas mileage not good
- scored low in safety
- road noise
|
Mazda CX-7 9 H1 x6 a( G3 y ^; `
7 l0 N& \1 e# H$ a
| #14 Editor's PickReasons to buy the Mazda CX-7:& p' P7 Z& J% L* a% f7 m8 e
# `" U' E! D* ?! P- #1 ranked in safety on the list
- #3 ranked in expert review
- #3 ranked in value
Reasons not to buy the Mazda CX-7:4 E) V4 {, H% M# A0 h* {) D
- could do better in gas mileage
- a bit pricy for the quality
|
BMW X3
" _ ^: r6 S3 ]. j6 b% }
+ w& z8 H* }( C# N$ U/ U& \0 V | #15 Editor's PickReasons to buy the BMW X3:
) y9 q0 ?7 v6 Z! g$ G: V9 S/ v
. v) S; ^1 b2 g7 C4 A! [( X- great horsepower
- very good value
- comfortable
Reasons not to buy the BMW X3:
" `: o8 T% ?6 q# S- low ranking for safety
- could do better in gas mileage
- #22 ranked for price
See reviews for this model' O) D5 i. }) |, N% N5 d
|
Suzuki XL7 , q- n% M& |. R
0 G8 J, h9 P0 R3 M! J' h2 y* ]" A
| #16 Editor's PickReasons to buy the Suzuki XL7:
- U8 k" L$ v+ _9 F- ] [( n' O, t& p! n, M+ ]' h1 d% f
- #3 ranked for horsepower
- Smooth V6
- exterior look
- controls easy to use
Reasons not to buy the Suzuki XL7:( N5 V0 S% w* K$ r7 w) `' M
- low ranked in value
- low ranked in price
- can do better in gas mileage
|
Acura RDX % {2 Y3 @6 x- L2 l7 L
2 C/ ]1 m _: `' R* F% ] | #17 Editor's PickReasons to buy the Acura RDX:% R) e& X' E+ _2 u
8 d1 C* |+ m4 D% H9 ?
- #3 ranked in value
- #6 ranked in horsepower
- luxurious interior
Reasons not to buy the Acura RDX:
$ W9 l7 b/ `% |6 u- k& a4 A- Scored low in safety
- can do better in gas mileage
- extremely sluggish off the line
See reviews for this model5 k0 J4 Q& F/ c% T+ z5 \/ `! ~- {
|
Chevrolet Equinox
: @3 [# s k: P9 n; a# }
) p" @! I& a) Y; m8 j3 S7 Y% m2 E; @ | #18 Editor's PickReasons to buy the Chevrolet Equinox:
+ V' F4 [1 O" ]: j
! Q" ]; Y5 i' Z1 u9 `9 C6 ]5 f- smooth ride
- exterior styling is nice
- has decent interior space
Reasons not to buy the Chevrolet Equinox:
( S2 a# g# k% A- ]9 u- cheap interior look
- can do better on gas
See reviews for this model
1 \1 Z) A4 M! |7 f, `, l( @' ^ |
Mitsubishi Outlander
+ Z: E( ~4 s( T9 m3 i
1 C8 x# i8 D! d, ^; V1 P | #19 Editor's PickReasons to buy the Mitsubishi Outlander:
" u% n! S% a$ L8 l1 z& ~# [
. C$ A+ h* y( n2 ~7 p' w- #3 ranked in value
- has decent horsepower
- comfortable
Reasons not to buy the Mitsubishi Outlander:
% T0 C2 D+ w- {, L, Q" X- low safety score
- can do better on gas mileage
- a bit pricy for the quality
|
Ford Escape
$ o# w- S2 b1 M& a
\! d- C" X7 l: G7 v4 a* z | #20 Editor's PickReasons to buy the Ford Escape:+ N9 M% \$ m' a/ _
0 W" w% J K9 f9 V! e& S3 k; G5 \3 n
- roomy
- Great mileage
- comfortable ride
- sporty look and feel
Reasons not to buy the Ford Escape:
7 f8 f2 f0 i$ i( |0 p7 e- lacks in horsepower
- scored low in value
- can do better in safety area
- road noise
See reviews for this model
. z) D, g! T m7 S( E5 }3 y |
Jeep Liberty " E- H+ _& L* G8 D6 D
$ t+ {2 J+ {( A7 W' @7 E# i
| #21 Editor's PickReasons to buy the Jeep Liberty:$ P D1 k9 a7 N. \
! I4 X* n/ Z3 D2 t4 f( U; D
- good low-end torque
- decent cargo compacity
- Rugged, sporty feel
Reasons not to buy the Jeep Liberty:% p8 w1 u1 ?8 ] B2 I
- can do better in gas mileage
- scored low in safety
- a bit pricy compared to others
See reviews for this model/ I* Z1 T+ C* O0 C6 {
|
Mercury Mariner
$ O2 d, C# |! _/ x; O
$ o0 o; R' y/ G) u" w& x9 U0 l' V | #22 Editor's PickReasons to buy the Mercury Mariner: w; [2 M* ?3 E0 `+ y
% K: r: C% e( @0 Y' {- J3 Z: P! J
- decent quality
- ok on gas mileage
- not too bad on price
Reasons not to buy the Mercury Mariner:" C' L) L8 ?4 h; H3 f4 e
- low safety score
- lower ranked on horsepower
- scored low in overall value
|