 鲜花( 0)  鸡蛋( 0)
|
世界上的事怕就怕认真二字。6 I# m/ x, y& W" u. @
收到Manulife GROUP RRSP 半年投资报告。
Z! z% {+ ~0 L, Y4 o; f g4 \0 S半年 : 5.8%
3 ]. Z: I1 c, M1 u6 B9 q1年 :18.9%+ s2 K& T. J3 G) M# Q* |
从2006年初开始: 14.1%$ k) A$ F' P: [6 M, q
: A- D6 f$ g6 @. G5 V
看起来不错,对我这种不炒股的人应该可以满足, 比起存银行强了N倍。 Y1 L: o3 z( c+ V7 O
. k* r3 Q; G5 |, b7 P世界上的事怕就怕认真二字。经过edmonton房事的教训,加上近半年的投资理财学习。决定进行认真的分析。1 R! J2 q, v$ |7 ?0 v
: s/ V3 `9 o' \. O我们公司RRSP都投资在Manulife GROUP fund内。 我有过几次调整, 但都集中在以下几种fund:
! Y' }' d& P) m# j; ? f5 ?
* }" O, ~8 G V7 |6 a# I0 ?) sThis table shows the historical annual compound total return of the Fund compared with the composite benchmark, as outlined in the Rate of return expectation below.; v) W6 \/ P$ l u- N
/ T/ P U, r J {+ K- T' d% y) n
Canadian Equity# _% j* A2 S' [ ]$ a( Y, @
1-year 2-year 3-year 5-year Since inception 6 K- D3 b0 q; ^, @2 I6 ?
MLI JF Canadian Equity 22.61% 17.57% 21.11% 17.20% 17.44% Oct 2001
; l/ X- G6 E! m G% c7 {S&P/TSX Total Return 22.73% 21.18% 20.12% 16.56% - # Y: Q6 G) h0 U3 q% B0 v
7 d+ U* K) e- t) @' h5 D
& w( J5 ]% w3 a( T/ `
1-year 2-year 3-year 5-year Since inception 4 c/ u8 i/ U4 E- k! K" j
MLI McLean Budden Canadian Equity 28.87% 22.26% 19.54% - 22.26% Apr 2003( S! G( k( f3 z: i- V0 @+ n
S&P/TSX Total Return 22.73% 21.18% 20.12% 16.56% - 1 l0 h3 o, r7 r( t7 F! `1 R: r
4 j# |2 _ O) _3 H9 ?
* r* O7 v9 y9 c4 D1 H3 d- O. P; HAsset Allocation
! f& S2 Z- d& M3 J, u& t8 _
$ Y+ m3 m# I" z 1-year 2-year 3-year 5-year Since inception
, X6 d: \. a# Q" w8 q( g0 rMLI Aggressive Asset Allocation 23.63% 18.58% 15.91% 13.86% 11.02% Feb 1999. w S7 M% i& C# T) M5 i, g3 m
Blend: MLI Aggressive Asset Allocation 22.08% 19.11% 16.63% 13.85% - - |/ W+ a- a) k; `" P( X- _
- u9 ]0 x; C) ~% t" x, [
: @1 |+ D. r3 C" R/ l 1-year 2-year 3-year 5-year Since inception
5 }& R0 T" T `6 x3 |# b7 u% G, A9 _MLI Growth Asset Allocation 20.25% 15.34% 13.66% 12.00% 9.64% Feb 1999/ c! h% k# h, f1 ]
Blend: MLI Growth Asset Allocation 18.42% 15.41% 13.83% 11.74% - / a3 A+ {% N9 j) T
- Q: e, Z; V2 G9 ]/ j1 j5 B看起来很美。 但前两种fund 的MER 分别是1.15 和1.2, 后两种是1.25
q) H& P# Z* y( G" z# B
/ P7 f$ R" L$ n% }' w再比较一下 index
1 v l9 W" ^0 z; I8 F# P
4 ]: T9 J- Z( r+ O0 q9 Y" n: ~6 R( `& Z3 P3 I
; x* @/ f m. H) ~- u/ R+ xFund Name 1 Mth 3 Mth 1 Yr 3 Yr 5 Yr 10 Yr
& V$ m: _7 }' ?$ M. ] ?) |1 X/ \TD International Index - I -0.5 -2.1 19.8 11.7 8.1 3.6
+ f) T0 V! l& p# f: o" @# i' v! PTD International Index - e -0.4 -1.9 20.8 12.7 9.2 ---
2 B+ y* {% g! g: P" o9 ^* _9 tTD European Index - I -0.6 -0.1 25.6 14.3 9.7 ---
( @' S! y2 o1 iTD European Index - e -0.5 0.1 26.1 14.8 10.2 ---
$ b# ?0 s* c% I6 HTD Dow Jones Industrial Avg Index - I -2.0 0.2 16.3 1.7 1.4 ---
9 Z! @, F) m9 F/ x9 ^3 `TD Dow Jones Industrial Avg Index - e -2.1 0.3 16.8 2.1 1.9 ---
% E0 p3 f/ Q& D- K3 W% qTD Canadian Index - I -0.9 6.1 21.9 19.1 15.7 9.3 2 K) v1 O/ h/ C/ j# I
TD Canadian Index - e -0.8 6.2 22.4 19.6 16.2 ---
) k: A. K- F( TTD Canadian Bond Index - I -0.3 -1.9 3.9 4.3 5.0 5.5 5 b% E" l4 X4 q
TD Canadian Bond Index - e -0.3 -1.9 4.3 4.7 5.4 ---
, \! P3 ^# d! {) a$ m9 G/ M4 R+ l1 ^9 [7 v: P
# T+ a5 O; U* h2 i/ aFund Name
2 a5 k' P& ?- [3 I* \/ p3 o(Click to select all) Morningstar Category RRSP Total Assets ($Mil) MER Legal Status 3 _: _4 l8 R, ~" l
TD International Index - I International Equity Yes 499.7 1.41 T
( {: Q; k; ~* r" y$ q: `TD International Index - e International Equity Yes 499.7 0.48 T 5 y9 y* J5 M, U8 C/ p, A8 U
TD European Index - I European Equity Yes 83.0 0.99 T
: \) K+ k$ ~* P: U: _3 o* J7 X) f. R4 [TD European Index - e European Equity Yes 83.0 0.48 T
6 C8 B7 ~6 {- y& UTD Dow Jones Industrial Avg Index - I US Equity Yes 46.6 0.88 T
/ w S6 L2 _9 O3 J+ n! g, |TD Dow Jones Industrial Avg Index - e US Equity Yes 46.6 0.31 T
' @2 @- w4 y0 Z, ~3 ^- F1 Z" ~0 ATD Canadian Index - I Canadian Equity Yes 869.6 0.88 T
4 h2 g; p& O* T- s( Z" TTD Canadian Index - e Canadian Equity Yes 869.6 0.31 T
* w2 C# |$ D( kTD Canadian Bond Index - I Canadian Core Fixed Income Yes 703.3 0.91 T
7 I$ e9 S1 \# o8 oTD Canadian Bond Index - e Canadian Core Fixed Income es 703.3 0.48 T- _) M5 Q, {4 _5 S3 g& @
# Z+ K$ g, n) L/ }
; ? A, B1 R# n那MLI JF Canadian Equity,MLI McLean Budden Canadian Equity 和TD Canadian Index - I,TD Canadian Index - e 比较一下,就会
/ J' l) }, U9 Y* A; V6 a发现 Mauulife fund 收益不但没有比过index, MER 约是index 的两倍。 买index 还可以完全不想事。
% r' z6 k J6 Y `
- W _& q8 `/ @/ |! _, ?结论: 即使是加入Group RRSP, MER已经比非GRoup 便宜,还是不如INDEX。不能简单的认为group RRSP 就划算了。适当时候,可以groupde
6 ~2 n+ M/ G' v9 G资金转到TD.* g2 M# I# N( B( l
3 O6 |) i) j$ i/ V
) N4 D% c1 }% i0 j; `4 p" g6 j请精打兄点评。不胜感激。。。 |
|